Feeding 5000 A Fish For A Day (with Jesus)

So here we are, the modern church, surrounded by homeless people (refugees of a burned out, selfish American Dream), and we sense (rightly) that Jesus would have us care… that he would have us DO SOMETHING.  And we want to help – really.  To REALLY help.  …well, sorta we want that, yeah.

And we discovered a long time ago, in fact even our grandparents knew this, that helping this problem never seems to really solve it.  The poor, it seems, you always have with you.  (I might have read that somewhere.)  And when you give a dollar to a wino, it gets spent on more wine.  So, we feel a little foolish for our efforts that seem to never get the traction we want.

Still, we feel compelled to do something.  But what?

Oh yeah… grandma always said, “Don’t give the bum money, he will just waste it on booze.  Instead, go buy a sandwich for him and give him something to eat instead.”  And this truly is wise advice!  A hungry person will not pass up fresh food.  And you can side step the waste of buying booze by doing this.

But somehow this still isn’t enough, we think.  And so we feel a bit perplexed, but sometimes we break down and give the money anyway.  We feel foolish for it, but it feels like Jesus would want us to.

Meanwhile, we vote conservative and listen to conservative talk radio hosts and so forth who rag on liberals for wasting money on the poor.  This makes us feel even more foolish, and a little torn.  Maybe even double minded.

But then some best-selling Bible teachers publish a book that tells us to rethink charity and to change the way we do it so as to be more “effective”.  And as part of that process, they even ask you to take an oath not to do for others what they can do for themselves.  They basically baptize the idea that if you feed a man a fish; you feed him for a day; but if you teach a man to fish, you can finally make him go away!

But Jesus just ain’t with that program.  Really.  Go read the gospels.

Take, for instance, the feeding of the 5000.  To be fair, this tale is not intended to be instructional about poverty relief.  But just because that is not its intended purpose does not mean it has nothing to do with it.  It does.  And we certainly see Jesus break all the rules of the best-selling Bible teachers who make it appear that there is no real conflict with your conservative politics and your Bible.

Jesus has his disciples get in a boat and cross the sea in an effort to get away from the mobs of needy people for a bit of rest.  But the mobs see where he is going and run there on foot ahead of the boats!  When they all meet up again, Jesus feels compassion for them because they are like sheep without a shepherd.  They are all in a desolate place where there is little or no resources.  And they are hungry and weary from running after Jesus!

The disciples have a brilliant idea.  They think Jesus should send the crowds away to the towns nearby to purchase food for themselves.  “Problem solved”, they think.  And the beauty of this is that they would not be doing for others what the others could be doing for themselves!  Wow!

There is just one problem.

Jesus doesn’t like the idea.  He says, “You feed them”.

Oh snap!

Yeah, you feed them.  And of course the disciples suddenly feel inadequate for the task.  But in Jesus’s hands, the crowds are fed – at least for one more day.  And that is just how Jesus wants it.  It points to him as God, as provider, as Manna From Heaven!  And that always was about making crowds of people dependent on him!

So, Jesus feeds 5000 for a day, and he gets them to stay!  And we could all take a note from that.



  1. Michael Wilson · February 11

    Right on target. It seems while Jesus does know the poor will always be with us, we can feed 5,000 today. “Give us this day our daily bread” is a part of his Manifesto.

    Be blessed.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Agent X · February 11


      Yeah… The story of Jesus feeding 5000 is multi layered and multi dimensional. There are a lot of directions I would like to take my analyses of it. And I am sure I am only scratching the surface!

      But I wrote this post with wiggly toddlers on my lap, and I try to keep these things short (sometimes) anyway. But if we go read the story of Moses leading Israel in the wilderness, which the Gospels want us to do as we consider this scene with them, it is clear that all of Israel is a mob of needy people addicted to their own slavery! They grumble and lament that they ever left Egypt! God (and Moe) get frustrated with them repeatedly!!! Yet, God wants them to ONLY take enough MANNA for each day. Any more than that will go to waste.

      It is clear that God does not want his people saving Manna up for tomorrow. He is not seeding a capitalist project. You can’t take some Manna for today, tomorrow, and some more to sell to other needy people when they run out. Those fools who can’t plan ahead and think about tomorrow’s need, ironically, are the ones TRUSTING God with their lives.

      And none of this negates the frustrations of dealing with needy addicts! It is frustrating. And quite often those of us not suffering homelessness, addiction, and mental illness do in fact know better than them. But still, we are in the Manna business, which is not really a business at all. And sure enough, it seems they never learn! This is nothing new!!!

      I am all for rethinking our charity, actually. But I am certain that a truly biblical analysis will shed a lot of our capitalist sensitivities for a start, and a lot of political sensitivities along with that. (And btw, I am a conservative! – not a regular run of the mill kind, but I am quite conservative over all.) But ending idol worship is always tough stuff. Trusting God is always a bewildering thing to do. But, ironically, this is something the bums themselves have a wealth of and stand ready to teach the rest of us, even as we struggle to love them.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Michael Wilson · February 11

        Thanks! Great insight. In my work, I help non-profits. Some Social Service types need work on their model, I think. God’s ways aren’t ours, that is for sure. Jesus shows us the way.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s